Where to Find the Best Ice Cream in Cleveland

Where to Find the Best Ice Cream in Cleveland

Long summer days are almost upon us, meaning it’s time to talk about everyone’s favorite summer treat: ice cream!

While ice cream shops in Cleveland aren’t quite as prolific as craft breweries and independent coffee shops, there are still a lot of cool spots to grab a sweet treat in the city.

The best ice cream shops in Cleveland

Here are all my favorite locally-owned shops that serve up the best ice cream in Cleveland:

1. Mitchell’s Ice Cream

Multiple locations

The best ice cream in Cleveland, Ohio

Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream has been an ice cream staple in Cleveland since Pete and Mike Mitchell opened their first shop in Westlake in 1999. The duo soon expanded to shops in Solon, Rocky River, Beachwood, and beyond, and opened their now-flagship store and kitchen in Ohio City in 2014. They now have 10 shops across the Greater Cleveland area.

My favorite Mitchell’s location is their Ohio City flagship store, where you can also go on behind-the-scenes tasting tours of their kitchen.

Inside Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream in Ohio City
Mitchell’s in Ohio City
Tour of Mitchell's Homemade Ice Cream
A peek into the Mitchell’s kitchen on a tasting tour

Mitchell’s serves up dozens of hand-crafted flavors of ice cream, yogurt, and sorbet, all made using as many Ohio-grown ingredients as possible. They have seasonal flavors like Lavender Honey in the spring, Campfire S’mores in the summer, Pumpkin Spice in the fall, and Peppermint Stick in the winter, plus all the regular favorites.

They also offer vegan and sugar-free options, as well as sundaes, shakes, cakes, and more.

2. Mason’s Creamery

4401 Bridge Ave, Cleveland

Mason's Creamery shop in Cleveland

If it’s innovative, Instagram-ready flavors of ice cream that you’re looking for, then you need look no further than Mason’s Creamery in Ohio City.

Mason’s is a small-batch ice cream shop known for its experimental flavors and making everything from scratch. They try new things all the time, whether it’s soft serve, ice cream donut sandwiches, or interesting collaborations with other local brands and businesses.

I love Mason’s shop, with its outdoor picnic tables and colorful murals; this is a great spot to hang out on a summer evening. AND, if you’re dairy-free, Mason’s has one of the largest selections of vegan-friendly flavors.

Ice cream from Mason's Creamery
Vegan sorbets at Mason’s

During the winter months, Mason’s does something extra unique and actually switches from serving ice cream to ramen noodles!

3. Honey Hut

Multiple locations

Exterior of Honey Hut shop

When I asked people on Twitter about their favorite Cleveland ice cream spots, one shop kept being mentioned: Honey Hut.

Honey Hut doesn’t actually have a location in downtown Cleveland, but it’s such a local favorite that I decided it deserved a spot on this list anyway. They’ve been serving ice cream in the area since 1974, and are known for using honey instead of sugar as a sweetener for their flavors.

Quarts of Honey Hut ice cream
I also love their adorable logo.

You’ll find 5 different Honey Hut locations in the Greater Cleveland area: in Brecksville (7304 Chippewa Rd.), Brunswick (922 Pearl Rd.), Old Brooklyn (4674 State Rd.), Parma (6250 State Rd.), and Solon (28300 Miles Rd.).

Honey Hut serves up 13 regular homemade flavors, along with extra seasonal ones that change monthly. Must-try flavors include their Honey Pecan (a take on a butter pecan) and Orange Blossom.

Cup of Honey Hut ice cream
Chocolate Peanut Butter and Sea Salt Caramel are also delicious

4. Sweet Moses

6800 Detroit Ave, Cleveland

Inside Sweet Moses soda fountain and treat shop
Inside Sweet Moses

Who doesn’t love an old-fashioned soda fountain and treat shop? That’s exactly what Sweet Moses is.

This Gordon Square favorite serves up classic ice cream flavors, sundaes, and fountain sodas from an authentic Bastion-Blessings soda fountain. Belly up to the counter and order a sundae and a Sweet Moses Root Beer, which they’ll pour for you right out of the barrel.

Exterior of Sweet Moses in Cleveland

This is an excellent place to take the kids – just maybe don’t let them order the Terminal Tower sundae, which comes with 10 scoops of ice cream and 5 toppings!

Sundae and root beer from Sweet Moses
Sweet Moses sundae and root beer

Sweet Moses also serves vegan and no-sugar-added ice cream, as well as phosphate sodas, chocolates, popcorn, and more.

5. Piccadilly Artisan Creamery

11607 Euclid Ave, Cleveland

Piccadilly Artisan Creamery

If you find yourself with an ice cream craving in the University Circle/Uptown area, make sure to stop in to Piccadilly Artisan Creamery. Not only do they serve up “farm to cone” ice cream that’s hand-crafted with local organic ingredients, but they also make their ice cream with liquid nitrogen!

Inside Piccadilly Artisan Creamery
Ice cream from Piccadilly Artisan Creamery
Carmelized Banana ice cream with chocolate chips and caramel drizzle

The experience of watching them make your order at Piccadilly is half the fun. You choose your flavor and mix-ins, and then they craft the ice cream with liquid nitrogen in large mixers right in front of your eyes.

Liquid nitrogen ice cream being made at Piccadilly Artisan Creamery
Watch the ice cream being made!

They say the liquid nitrogen makes the ice cream extra creamy – and this certainly seems to be true!

6. Tremont Scoops

2362 Professor Ave, Cleveland

Tremont Scoops ice cream shop

Tremont Scoops calls itself “Tremont’s neighborhood ice cream shop,” and that’s exactly what it feels like inside – the local go-to spot for cones and cups in the heart of Tremont. The inside of the shop decorated in shades of pink, and comes complete with a couple indoor swings.

Inside Tremont Scoops ice cream shop
Tremont Scoops ice cream shop

The shop serves up 24 different flavors (with some being swapped out seasonally), with everything being sourced from the Greater Cleveland area. I really like their raspberry truffle and blueberry cheesecake flavors.

Ice cream cone from Tremont Scoops
Raspberry Truffle – yum!

Along with ice cream, Tremont Scoops also offers milkshakes, sundaes, ice cream sandwiches, and chocolate covered bananas. If you like salty with your sweet, order your ice cream in one of their pretzel cones.

Honorable Mention 1: Cathy’s Gourmet Ice Cream Sandwiches

401 Euclid Ave., Cleveland

Level up your ice cream experience – by putting it in between a pair of delicious cookies! Cathy’s is located inside the Cleveland Arcade, and serves up regular ice cream, but is (obviously) most known for its massive ice cream sandwiches.

Honorable mention 2: Addicted Coffee and Ice Cream

13743 Madison Ave, Lakewood

To be fair, Lakewood’s Addicted doesn’t *just* do ice cream. They also serve up espresso drinks and cold brew, cookies and muffins, and even sandwiches. But the shop went viral earlier this year for their new Crazy Shakes – which, yes, are indeed crazy.

Just be aware that these crazy milkshake concoctions cost about $15 (but they are definitely meant to be shared).

Great ice cream shops a little further away

Still looking for more great local ice cream shops in the Greater Cleveland area? You can also check out:

  • Kamms Corners Ice Cream Company – A Rocky River favorite
  • 0º Below – This spot in Cleveland Heights served up unique Thai rolled ice cream
  • Graeter’s Ice Cream – based in Cincinnati, Graeter’s now also has locations in Beachwood and Westlake)
  • Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream & Yogurt – This Youngstown-based ice cream chain has locations in Broadview Heights, Northfield, and Twinsburg, with a downtown Cleveland location coming soon.

An ice cream note: Not all of these Cleveland ice cream shops remain open during the winter months, so please check times online if you’re visiting in the winter!

Where’s YOUR favorite spot to get ice cream in Cleveland?

Pin it for later:

This Post Has 2 Comments

  1. Cliff Skodak

    Please send information and address of ice cream locations locally

    1. Amanda

      Hey Cliff! This is a list of local ice cream places in Cleveland, Ohio. Addresses are listed, but you’re not likely to find any of these in Florida, I’m afraid, since they are all found in northeast Ohio.

Leave a Reply